Two countries, different systems, common goals

Vocational education systems are shaped by local realities, but many challenges and opportunities are shared. By comparing approaches in Switzerland and Canada, the project opens up new ways of thinking about education, employability, and innovation. 


Switzerland

The Swiss Vocational Education and Training (VET) system is a cornerstone of Switzerland’s education and economic success. It is internationally recognised for its strong labour‑market orientation, high quality, and low youth unemployment. The system combines practical training in companies with theoretical education in vocational schools and is based on close cooperation between the public sector and the private economy.

 

1. Basic Structure
 

After completing compulsory education (usually at age 15), young people in Switzerland can choose between two main pathways:

  • General education (academic upper secondary schools leading to universities)
  • Vocational education and training (VET)

Around two thirds of young people opt for vocational education, making VET the most common pathway at upper secondary level.

 

2. Dual System: Learning at Work and at School

The core of the Swiss VET system is the dual model:

  • Practical training takes place in a company (usually 3–4 days per week)
  • Theoretical education takes place at a vocational school (1–2 days per week)
  • Intercompany courses complement training with standardized practical skills

This structure ensures that learners acquire job‑relevant skills while gaining real work experience.

 

3. Types of Upper Secondary VET Programs
 

At upper secondary level, Switzerland offers three main VET qualifications:

Two-year VET program (Federal VET Certificate)

  • Practice‑oriented
  • Designed for learners with a stronger practical focus
  • Leads directly to employment

Three- or four-year VET program (Federal VET Diploma)

  • The standard form of apprenticeship
  • Leads to a nationally recognised qualification
  • Allows progression to higher education

 Vocational Baccalaureate (Berufsmaturität)

  • Can be completed during or after an apprenticeship
  • Provides access to Universities of Applied Sciences
  • Strengthens general and academic competencies

 

4. Tertiary Level: Professional Education
 

After completing upper secondary VET, graduates can continue to professional education and training at tertiary level, which includes:

  • Professional examinations
  • Advanced professional examinations
  • Colleges of Higher Education (Höhere Fachschulen)

This pathway allows professionals to specialise, advance to leadership roles, or become experts in their field without following a traditional university route.

 

5. Governance and Responsibilities

The Swiss VET system is based on a partnership model involving three main actors:

  • Confederation (Federal level)
     Sets strategic goals, ensures quality, and regulates national standards.
  • Cantons
     Implement VET, supervise vocational schools, and support learners and companies.
  • Professional organisations and companies
     Define occupational profiles, provide apprenticeships, and ensure labour‑market relevance.

This shared responsibility ensures that training content remains up to date and aligned with economic needs.

 

6. Labour Market Orientation
 

A defining feature of Swiss VET is its strong labour‑market relevance:

  • Training occupations are regularly updated
  • Curricula are based on occupational competencies
  • Employers are directly involved in training and assessment

As a result, graduates are well prepared for employment, and companies benefit from a skilled workforce.

 

7. Permeability and Lifelong Learning

The Swiss system is highly permeable:

  • Learners can move between vocational and academic pathways
  • Vocational graduates can access higher education
  • Adult education and continuing training are strongly supported

This flexibility supports lifelong learning and adaptability in a changing labour market.

 

8. Social Value and International Recognition
 
 

Vocational education in Switzerland enjoys high social esteem. Apprenticeships are not seen as a second‑choice option but as an attractive and respected pathway with excellent career prospects.

Internationally, the Swiss VET system is often cited as a best‑practice model due to:

  • Low youth unemployment
  • Strong employer engagement
  • Smooth school‑to‑work transitions

 

The Swiss Vocational Education and Training system combines practical experience, theoretical knowledge, and strong employer involvement. Its dual structure, permeability, and close alignment with labour‑market needs make it a powerful and sustainable model for skills development, economic competitiveness, and social inclusion.

Canada

Canada’s vocational education and training (VET) system is diverse, decentralised, and strongly oriented toward labour‑market needs. Unlike countries with a single national VET framework, Canada’s system is shaped by provincial and territorial responsibility, resulting in regional variation but shared core principles: employability, flexibility, and lifelong learning. 

 

1. Governance and Responsibilities
 

Education in Canada is primarily the responsibility of the 13 provinces and territories. There is no federal ministry of education. Each province or territory regulates: 

  • Vocational programs
  • Apprenticeships
  • Certification and credentials
  • Quality assurance of institutions

The federal government plays a supporting role by: 

  • Funding apprenticeship incentives and loans
  • Supporting Indigenous education and skills training
  • Coordinating labour‑market information and statistics
  • Promoting interprovincial mobility (e.g. Red Seal Program) 

 

2. Position of VET in the Education System
 

Vocational education in Canada is located mainly at the post‑secondary level, after completion of secondary school (high school). In contrast to countries with strong upper‑secondary VET systems, Canada places most vocational training in: 

  • Colleges and institutes
  • Polytechnics
  • Apprenticeship programs

Upper‑secondary vocational programs exist in some provinces, but they play a relatively minor role nationally. 

 

3. Main Pathways of Vocational Education
 

Canada’s VET system offers several main pathways: 

 

a) Colleges, Institutes, and Polytechnics 

Publicly funded colleges and institutes offer: 

  • Certificates (usually 1 year or less)
  • Diplomas (2–3 years)
  • Applied bachelor’s degrees (in some institutions)

 

Programs focus on practical, career‑oriented training in fields such as: 

  • Business and administration
  • Health and social services
  • Engineering technologies
  • Information technology
  • Hospitality and creative industries

 

Curricula are typically developed in cooperation with industry partners to ensure labour‑market relevance. 

 

b) Apprenticeship Training 

Apprenticeships are a central component of vocational education in Canada, particularly in the skilled trades. 

 

Key characteristics: 

  • Combination of paid on‑the‑job training and in‑class technical instruction
  • Most training occurs in the workplace
  • Programs typically last between two and five years, depending on the trade
  • Apprentices are employed and earn wages during training
  •  

Apprenticeship systems are regulated at provincial and territorial level, leading to regional differences in structure and duration. 

 

c) Red Seal Program 

The Red Seal Program is a national standard for certain skilled trades. 

  • Recognises a common level of competency across provinces and territories
  • Allows certified tradespeople to work anywhere in Canada without re‑certification
  • Covers a wide range of major trades

 

This program enhances labour mobility and national coherence within a decentralised system. 

 

4. Credentials and Qualifications
 

Vocational education leads to a variety of credentials, including: 

  • Certificates and diplomas from colleges
  • Journeyperson certificates in the skilled trades
  • Red Seal endorsement (for designated trades)

There is no single national qualifications framework, but credentials are widely recognised within provinces and, in many cases, across Canada. 

 

5. Labour‑Market Orientation 

 

Canadian VET is strongly aligned with labour‑market needs: 

  • Programs are designed to meet regional economic demand
  • Industry advisory boards are common in colleges
  • Applied learning, internships, and work placements are widely used

According to OECD data, a significant share of young adults in Canada hold vocational or professionally oriented post‑secondary qualifications, particularly at short‑cycle tertiary level. 

 

6. Permeability and Lifelong Learning 

 

The Canadian system places strong emphasis on flexibility: 

  • Learners can move between vocational and academic pathways
  • Credits may be transferred between colleges and universities
  • Adult learners and career changers are a key target group

Continuing education, part‑time study, and upskilling programs are widely available, supporting lifelong learning and workforce adaptation. 

 

7. Strengths and Challenges 

 

Strengths 

  • Strong responsiveness to labour‑market needs
  • High flexibility and multiple entry points
  • Well‑developed apprenticeship system in skilled trades
  • Good opportunities for adult learners

 

Challenges 

  • Fragmentation due to decentralised governance
  • Limited visibility and status of vocational pathways compared to universities
  • Variation in access and outcomes across regions

 

The Canadian vocational education and training system is characterised by decentralisation, diversity, and flexibility. With its strong focus on post‑secondary vocational education, apprenticeships, and applied learning, it provides multiple pathways into skilled employment and supports lifelong learning. While the lack of a unified national framework creates complexity, strong labour‑market alignment and interprovincial coordination mechanisms ensure the system remains effective and adaptable. 

The impact

The impact of the successful Learning by Going Switzerland-Canada project is multifaceted. Firstly, it creates an institutional exchange between the two countries at the national level for the first time, particularly in a field that is organized very differently. While colleges and full-time school-based education dominate in Canada, dual education is excellently established in Switzerland. Both countries can benefit from each other. For the two regions of St. Gallen and Solothurn, this exchange with Vancouver, supported by the Consulate General in Vancouver, offers an excellent platform to present vocational education even more prominently—in the media, on social media, and in physical practice. At the local level, all stakeholders of the participating schools, especially the GBS St. Gallen and the BBZ Olten, benefit from the visits, the exchange with participating training companies, and the development of a long-term network. This exchange helps prioritize and promote Swiss vocational education and training internationally and supports the diverse efforts of the SPFI for international collaboration